People Hate Vivi’s Casting as Charithra Chandran – One Piece Season 2 Controversy Explained
Image : Toei Animation
By
Patel
|
August 23, 2025
One Piece Live Action Season 2 has only just revealed its first look, and yet fans are already divided over the casting of Princess Vivi. Netflix announced that Charithra Chandran will play the beloved princess from the Alabasta arc, but the reaction online has been harsh. Many fans have criticized the casting, claiming that Vivi should be “fair-skinned and beautiful,” while others believe Chandran’s darker complexion doesn’t match their perception of the character.
The Backlash Against Charithra Chandran
Shortly after the trailer dropped, criticism began trending on X/Twitter. Some One Piece fans argued that Oda’s original design portrayed Vivi as pale-skinned, and they expected the live-action to reflect that look exactly. These complaints quickly turned into targeted hate toward Chandran.
But here’s the reality: Nefertari Vivi’s roots lie in Alabasta, a kingdom that draws clear inspiration from Middle Eastern and South Asian culture. As one viral comment explained:
“But let’s talk facts: ‘Nefertari’ is Egyptian. Where is Egypt? The Middle East. The kingdom of Alabasta draws heavily from Middle Eastern and Southern Asian culture. And you’re complaining because the actor chosen to play the role… isn’t white?! Do you know how ridiculous you sound?! Representation matters. Casting Charithra isn’t changing the character—it’s actually honoring Oda’s intended vision.”
This argument highlights the bigger picture: One Piece’s world is vast, diverse, and culturally inspired. Expecting every character to look “Western” is not only inaccurate but also against Oda’s global storytelling vision.
Emily Rudd Defends Charithra Chandran
Image :Toei Animation
Emily Rudd, who plays Nami in the live-action, openly defended her new co-star. She reminded fans that Eiichiro Oda himself hand-selected Charithra Chandran for the role:
Her emotions were a mix of joy and disbelief—she couldn’t believe that the mythical figure she had only heard about was standing in front of her in the form of Straw Hat Luffy. At that moment, Vegapunk revealed the truth:
“Charithra was hand-selected by Oda, so there’s no need to be sad or upset. This isn’t about her skin tone. We haven’t even seen her performance yet, and knowing her talent, she’s going to be incredible.”
Emily’s words remind fans of the most important fact: Oda knows his characters better than anyone else, and if he trusts Charithra to embody Vivi, then that’s the only validation that matters.
Wapol Actor’s Strong Words Against Haters
Even Colton Osorio Colletti (who plays Wapol) spoke out against the hate:
“Charithra was hand-selected by Oda, and he has far more knowledge and understanding of his own characters than anyone else—certainly more than the hateful, unimaginative creeps who have the audacity to throw hate at an actor without even seeing their performance.”
His statement further proves how strongly the cast stands together in supporting Chandran.
📢 Let’s Talk!
The casting controversy surrounding One Piece Season 2 shows how easily fandoms can become toxic when expectations clash with reality. But remember—we haven’t even seen Charithra Chandran’s performance yet. Judging an actor based solely on appearance is unfair, especially when Oda himself approved the casting.
One Piece has always celebrated diversity, culture, and acceptance. If Oda trusts Charithra to bring Vivi to life, maybe it’s time fans trust him too.
👇 Share your thoughts in the comments below — let’s discuss!
